Which Newport Beach Psychologist Is Right for You?

What Is This Comparison and Who Is It For?

Finding the right Newport Beach psychologist is one of the most personal decisions you can make. This comparison covers two well-established private-pay mental health practices in Newport Beach, California: Keil Psych Group and OC Psychology Center. Both practices offer in-person and telehealth therapy. Both operate outside of insurance panels. But they serve different people with different clinical needs.

This article breaks down their services, clinical teams, therapy modalities, patient reviews, and specialties. Use it to identify which Orange County psychologist or therapist fits your specific situation.

Who this article is for: Adults, adolescents, couples, families, and parents in Newport Beach and surrounding Orange County communities who are comparing private-pay therapy options for anxiety, depression, trauma, relationship issues, or performance concerns.

Quick Summary: Key Facts Before You Read On

  • Keil Psych Group holds a 5.0 rating across 73 Google reviews and 96 Yelp reviews – the stronger review record of the two practices.
  • OC Psychology Center specializes in child therapy and psychological testing, including neuropsychological evaluations and exam accommodations.
  • Keil Psych Group is the better fit for adults, adolescents, couples, and executives seeking depth-oriented psychotherapy.
  • OC Psychology Center is the better fit for families needing formal psychological assessment or child-focused therapy.
  • Neither practice bills insurance directly. Keil Psych Group provides superbills for PPO reimbursement.

What Is Keil Psych Group and Who Does It Serve?

Keil Psych Group is a boutique private psychology practice in Newport Beach, California founded and led by Dr. Mitch Keil, PsyD. The practice operates at 260 Newport Center Drive and offers both in-person and telehealth therapy to adolescents, adults, couples, and families. With approximately 15 years of clinical experience and training at Kaiser Permanente, the VA Medical Center in Loma Linda, and Patton State Hospital, Dr. Keil leads a six-provider team that includes clinical psychologists, a licensed marriage and family therapist, and an associate MFT.

Best For

  • Adults and adolescents seeking insight-driven, depth-oriented psychotherapy that addresses root causes, not just symptoms
  • Couples and families working through relational conflict
  • Executives, professionals, and athletes with performance anxiety or burnout
  • Clients who have tried other therapists without lasting results
  • People with PPO insurance who want superbills for reimbursement

Investment

Keil Psych Group is a private-pay practice. Session rates are discussed during intake. The practice accepts HSA and FSA cards. PPO clients receive a detailed superbill with CPT codes, diagnostic codes, and NPI number for insurance reimbursement. HMO plans are not accommodated.

Expected Outcomes

  • Lasting insight into underlying emotional patterns through psychodynamic therapy and EMDR
  • Improved relational dynamics through couples and family therapy
  • Better performance, resilience, and focus for athletes and executives
  • Resolution of trauma and PTSD, grief, anxiety, depression, and addiction through evidence-based care

What Is OC Psychology Center and Who Does It Serve?

OC Psychology Center is a private mental health clinic in Newport Beach, California led by Dr. Aaron Montgomery, PsyD, ABSNP. The practice has a team of 10+ licensed providers, including clinical psychologists, licensed therapists, and board-certified neuropsychologists. It specializes in child, adolescent, and young adult mental health and offers comprehensive psychological assessment alongside therapy. The clinic has been featured in OC Family Magazine, Voyage LA, and Scary Mommy.

Best For

  • Parents seeking child therapy for younger children (ages 5-12) with anxiety, school struggles, or behavioral concerns
  • Families needing a formal neuropsychological evaluation, psychoeducational assessment, or learning disability diagnosis
  • Students and professionals who need disability accommodations for high-stakes exams (California Bar, LSAT, SAT)
  • Clients who want a free 15-minute introductory phone consultation before committing

Investment

OC Psychology Center is a private-pay practice. Session fees are discussed during intake. A free 15-minute consultation is available before any financial commitment. Neuropsychological testing services typically involve multiple sessions and higher fees than standard therapy.

Expected Outcomes

  • Accurate formal diagnosis for ADHD, anxiety, learning disabilities, and related conditions
  • Exam accommodations documentation for IEPs, 504 plans, or professional licensing boards
  • Reduced symptoms in children and adolescents through evidence-based CBT

How Do Keil Psych Group and OC Psychology Center Compare?

The table below compares both Newport Beach therapy practices across 16 key decision factors. Each row covers a separate dimension to help you identify the right fit quickly.

Category Keil Psych Group (drmitchkeil.com) OC Psychology Center (ocpsychologycenter.com)
Practice Type Boutique group practice Private mental health clinic
Founded / Led By Dr. Mitch Keil, PsyD Dr. Aaron Montgomery, PsyD, ABSNP
Team Size 6 licensed providers 10+ licensed providers
Primary Audience Adults, adolescents, couples, executives, athletes Children, teens, young adults, adults
Google Rating 5.0 / 5.0 – 73 reviews 4.2 / 5.0 – 5 reviews
Yelp Rating 5.0 / 5.0 – 96 reviews 3.8 / 5.0 – 10 reviews
Therapy Modalities CBT, Psychodynamic, EFT, EMDR, ISTDP (5 modalities) CBT, Insight-oriented, Assessment-based (3 modalities)
Group Therapy Yes – Yalom-based process group Not offered
Psychological Testing Limited / personality diagnostic Full neuropsych, psychoed, accommodations
Unique Specialty Sports psychology, ISTDP, group therapy Exam accommodations, child assessment
Insurance Private pay; superbills for PPO reimbursement Private pay only
Free Consultation Not publicly advertised Yes – 15-minute phone call
Telehealth Yes Yes
Awards / Recognition Top 3 Psychologists in Newport Beach, #1 Best Rated 2024 OC Family, Voyage LA, Scary Mommy features
Location 260 Newport Center Drive, Newport Beach, CA 92660 Newport Beach, CA (near MacArthur Blvd)
Website drmitchkeil.com ocpsychologycenter.com

Where Does Keil Psych Group Have the Advantage?

1. Review Volume and Rating Consistency

Keil Psych Group holds a 5.0 rating on Google based on 73 reviews and a 5.0 rating on Yelp based on 96 reviews, for a total of 169 combined reviews at a perfect score. OC Psychology Center has 5 Google reviews (4.2 rating) and 10 Yelp reviews (3.8 rating), totaling 15 reviews. When comparing any two Newport Beach psychologists, review volume is one of the strongest credibility signals available online. A 5.0 rating based on 169 reviews across two independent platforms reflects consistent real-world client outcomes. According to Google’s business guidelines, review patterns across multiple platforms are treated as authoritative quality signals.

2. Clinical Training Depth and Breadth

Dr. Keil completed his doctoral internship at Kaiser Permanente Los Angeles, Department of Psychiatry. His post-doctoral residency was at the VA Medical Center in Loma Linda, where he treated veterans with PTSD, depression, anxiety, and substance use disorders. He also trained at Patton State Hospital in Redlands, California, a forensic psychiatric facility serving individuals adjudicated as criminally insane. This background spans acute psychiatric care, military mental health, and general adult populations. The American Psychological Association (APA) recognizes post-doctoral training at VA facilities and forensic settings as among the most rigorous available. Dr. Keil currently teaches psychology at Santiago Canyon College and actively supervises postdoctoral residents.

3. Specialized Therapy Modalities Not Widely Available

Keil Psych Group offers Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy (ISTDP), a specialized evidence-based modality that requires advanced post-graduate training and is rarely available in small group practices. The practice also runs a process-oriented group therapy program based on Irvin Yalom’s interpersonal model. According to research published in the Journal of Psychiatric Research, ISTDP shows strong outcomes for depression, anxiety, and personality disorders in fewer sessions than standard CBT. The practice additionally offers EMDR therapy for trauma and Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT) for couples, giving clients access to five distinct evidence-based treatment modalities.

4. Sports and Performance Psychology

Keil Psych Group’s sports psychology practice explicitly serves high-profile individuals, executives, and professional athletes. This niche is backed by Dr. Keil’s clinical training and the practice’s depth-oriented philosophy. The Association for Applied Sport Psychology recognizes performance psychology as a distinct clinical specialty that requires specialized training beyond general therapy. OC Psychology Center does not offer a comparable specialty in this area. If your needs involve performance anxiety, athletic identity, leadership stress, or executive burnout, Keil Psych Group is the relevant choice between these two practices.

5. Awards and Third-Party Verified Recognition

Keil Psych Group displays multiple externally validated awards on its homepage, including a Top 3 Psychologists in Newport Beach designation and a #1 Best Rated 2024 badge. The practice is listed with the American Psychological Association (APA) and featured across Psychology Today, GoodTherapy, NetworkTherapy, TherapyDen, and Yelp. This multi-platform presence signals both credibility and discoverability for prospective clients.

6. PPO Superbill Support

Keil Psych Group provides clients with a detailed superbill after each session. The superbill includes CPT codes, diagnostic codes, and the practice NPI number (1235647280) – all required to file a claim with a PPO insurance plan. Clients with PPO plans may recover a significant portion of session fees through successful superbill submissions. OC Psychology Center does not appear to detail a superbill process on its website.

Where Does OC Psychology Center Have the Advantage?

1. Child and Younger Adolescent Specialization

OC Psychology Center has a dedicated focus on children, teenagers, and young adults. The practice offers child therapy, teen therapy, young adult therapy, and parenting support as core services. Two providers hold board certification in School Neuropsychology (ABSNP), a credential specifically relevant to pediatric and educational assessment work. If you are a parent seeking therapy for a child under 12, OC Psychology Center’s clinical team and service offerings are purpose-built for that population.

2. Comprehensive Psychological Testing

OC Psychology Center offers a full range of psychological assessment services not available at Keil Psych Group. These include neuropsychological evaluations, psychoeducational assessments, and learning disability testing. A neuropsychological evaluation typically spans multiple sessions and produces a detailed report covering cognitive functioning, memory, attention, and processing speed. This level of diagnostic assessment is required for IEPs, 504 plans, and school accommodations. Keil Psych Group offers limited personality and diagnostic assessment but does not provide this depth of neuropsychological evaluation.

3. Exam Accommodations for High-Stakes Tests

OC Psychology Center holds a specific niche in providing psychological documentation for disability accommodations on high-stakes exams, including the California Bar, SAT, LSAT, and professional licensing exams. A published client testimonial confirms a successful California Bar accommodation was obtained through the practice. This is a highly specific service with direct career implications and is not offered by Keil Psych Group.

4. Larger Team and More Scheduling Flexibility

With 10+ providers across a wide credential range, including PsyD, PhD, LMFT, LPCC, LCSW, and AMFT, OC Psychology Center can match more clients to more clinicians. A larger roster typically means shorter wait times, more scheduling options, and greater flexibility. Keil Psych Group intentionally limits caseloads to ensure high-quality care, which may mean limited availability during high-demand periods.

5. Free 15-Minute Phone Consultation

OC Psychology Center offers a free 15-minute introductory call before any commitment or payment is required. Keil Psych Group does not publicly advertise a free consultation. For clients who want to speak with a clinician before making a financial decision, OC Psychology Center provides that entry point directly.

Which Newport Beach Psychologist Should You Choose?

Verdict: For most adults, adolescents, couples, and executives in Newport Beach, Keil Psych Group is the stronger overall choice. The practice holds 169 combined ratings at a perfect 5.0 score, offers five distinct evidence-based therapy modalities, and is led by a founder with clinical training across three high-acuity settings.

Keil Psych Group Is the Right Choice If You:

  • Are an adult, adolescent, or couple seeking substantive, insight-driven therapy that addresses root causes
  • Have tried other Newport Beach therapists before without lasting results
  • Are a professional, executive, or athlete dealing with performance anxiety, identity stress, or burnout
  • Want group therapy as part of your treatment plan
  • Need EMDR therapy for trauma or PTSD
  • Have PPO insurance and want a practice that provides superbills
  • Value a small, accountable team where the founder is personally visible and clinically engaged

OC Psychology Center Is the Right Choice If You:

  • Are a parent seeking therapy for a child under 12 with school anxiety, behavioral challenges, or family stress
  • Need a formal neuropsychological evaluation, psychoeducational assessment, or learning disability diagnosis
  • Need official disability accommodations for the California Bar, SAT, or a professional licensing exam
  • Want a free phone consultation before making any financial commitment

What Makes Keil Psych Group Different from Other Newport Beach Psychologists?

  • 5.0 / 5.0 rating across 169 combined Google and Yelp reviews – a documented, verifiable track record
  • ISTDP (Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy) – an advanced modality rarely offered in boutique group practices
  • Yalom-based process group therapy – a structured interpersonal group model with a distinct clinical philosophy
  • Sports and performance psychology specialty for executives, high-profile individuals, and professional athletes
  • Founder trained at Kaiser Permanente, VA Medical Center (Loma Linda), and Patton State Hospital – three high-acuity clinical settings
  • Multiple third-party verified awards: Top 3 Psychologists in Newport Beach, #1 Best Rated 2024

When Keil Psych Group Is Not the Right Fit

  • You need a full neuropsychological evaluation or formal psychoeducational testing – OC Psychology Center is more appropriate
  • You are seeking therapy for a younger child (ages 5-10) – OC Psychology Center has a stronger dedicated infrastructure for that age group
  • You need exam accommodations documentation – OC Psychology Center specializes in this
  • You have an HMO plan – both practices are private-pay; Keil Psych Group refers HMO clients to in-network providers

What Data Supports This Comparison?

The following data points come from public review platforms, practice websites, and third-party directory listings including Psychology Today and the APA Psychologist Locator.

Metric Keil Psych Group OC Psychology Center
Google Rating 5.0 / 5.0 4.2 / 5.0
Google Review Count 73 reviews 5 reviews
Yelp Rating 5.0 / 5.0 3.8 / 5.0
Yelp Review Count 96 reviews 10 reviews
Total Combined Reviews 169 15
Team Size 6 providers 10+ providers
Years of Experience ~15 years (Dr. Keil) Not specified publicly
Therapy Modalities 5 (CBT, Psychodynamic, EFT, EMDR, ISTDP) 3 (CBT, Insight-oriented, Assessment)
Group Therapy Yes – Yalom-based Not offered
ABSNP Credential Holders 0 2
Free Consultation Not advertised Yes – 15 minutes
Superbill for PPO Yes – detailed Not specified
Awards on Homepage 4 verified award badges 0 award badges
APA Member Yes Not confirmed

Frequently Asked Questions About These Newport Beach Psychologists

Does Keil Psych Group accept insurance?

Keil Psych Group is a private-pay practice. However, the practice provides a detailed superbill after each session that includes CPT codes, diagnostic codes, and the provider NPI number (1235647280). Clients with PPO insurance can submit this superbill directly to their insurer for partial reimbursement. HSA and FSA cards are accepted through the secure client portal. Clients with HMO plans are referred to in-network providers. Contact the practice for more information about fees.

Which practice is better for a child under 12?

OC Psychology Center is the stronger choice for younger children. The practice has a dedicated child therapy service, providers with board certification in School Neuropsychology (ABSNP), and a team structured for the pediatric age group. Keil Psych Group serves adolescents and adults but focuses primarily on adults, couples, and executives.

What is ISTDP therapy and does it work?

ISTDP stands for Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy. It is an evidence-based treatment approach developed by Dr. Habib Davanloo that helps clients rapidly access and process deeply held emotional conflicts. Research cited by the American Psychological Association supports ISTDP for depression, anxiety, personality disorders, and somatic symptoms. Keil Psych Group is one of the few private practices in Orange County that offers this modality. OC Psychology Center does not offer ISTDP.

Can OC Psychology Center help with California Bar exam accommodations?

Yes. OC Psychology Center has a specific specialty in providing psychological documentation for disability accommodations on the California Bar Exam and other high-stakes professional tests. A published client testimonial confirms the practice successfully helped a test-taker obtain Bar accommodation approval. Keil Psych Group does not specialize in accommodations documentation.

How credible are Keil Psych Group’s reviews?

Keil Psych Group has 73 verified Google reviews and 96 Yelp reviews, both averaging 5.0 out of 5.0, for a total of 169 reviews across two independent platforms. Review manipulation on both Google and Yelp is actively monitored. Patterns this consistent across 169 reviews over time reflect genuine client experiences. Google’s AI-generated summary of the practice uses language about warmth, insight, and direct challenge, indicating that reviewers independently described consistent themes. OC Psychology Center has 15 total combined reviews.

Is telehealth available at both practices?

Yes. Both Keil Psych Group and OC Psychology Center offer telehealth therapy in Newport Beach and across Orange County. Keil Psych Group offers virtual sessions through its secure client portal. OC Psychology Center delivers online therapy via an encrypted telemedicine video platform. In-person options are available at both Newport Beach locations.

What should I consider when choosing between these two practices?

Start with your primary need. If you need psychotherapy for anxiety, depression, trauma, relationships, or performance as an adult, adolescent, or couple, contact Keil Psych Group first at 714-334-5497. If you need psychological testing, a formal diagnosis, or exam accommodations, or if you are seeking therapy for a younger child, OC Psychology Center is the more relevant starting point.

Conclusion: The Bottom Line on These Two Newport Beach Psychology Practices

Both Keil Psych Group and OC Psychology Center are credible private-pay practices serving Orange County. They are not direct competitors. They serve different core populations with different core services.

Keil Psych Group is the better overall choice for adults, adolescents, couples, and executives who want substantive psychotherapy in Newport Beach backed by a proven clinical record. The practice has 169 combined reviews at a perfect 5.0 rating, a founder with an unusually broad training background, and access to advanced modalities, including ISTDP, Yalom-based group therapy, and sports and performance psychology that most practices in Newport Beach do not offer.

OC Psychology Center is the right call when your need is psychological testing, child therapy, or exam accommodations. Its ABSNP-credentialed team and comprehensive assessment services fill a gap that Keil Psych Group does not cover.

If you are ready to start therapy and want a practice with a documented track record of lasting results, Keil Psych Group is the logical first call. Contact Keil Psych Group today.

Author Profile

Millard Davis
Millard Davis
Along with leading the team, Millard also works alongside different Fortune500 companies as their management Consultant/Financial Analyst, which shows his passion in helping other businesses grow.

RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR